Business Money and Political Corruption in Ireland

Mahon

By Iain McMenamin

The study of corruption and political finance in Ireland has tended to be qualitative.  This has made it difficult to determine whether problems related to a relatively small number of individuals of the system as a whole.  My article, “Business Financing of Politics in Ireland: Theory, Evidence and Reform” in the current issue of Irish Political Studies uses disclosed data to study the potential for corruption. The graph below shows some striking patterns.  Donations in general were given to both government and opposition.  By contrast, there was a clear bias towards TDs from governing parties in donations from businesses and an even stronger bias towards governing parties from the property sector.  It is highly unlikely that such donations involved a direct exchange of money for policy benefits.  However, it is very possible that such donations could underpin reciprocal exchanges, whereby TDs or their parties, might feel obliged to give extra attention to the needs of a donor business, perhaps at a time long after the donation itself.  Reciprocity is an important motivation for business donations in other jurisdictions as I show in my recently published book, If Money Talks, What Does It Say?  Corruption and Business Financing of Political Parties (Oxford 2013).

Image

Recent legislation has made it very onerous for businesses to donate even tiny amounts to politics.  However, many business contributions to politics come disguised as individual donations or as commercial transactions.  The recent legislation also requires the parties to furnish audited accounts.  The Standards in Public Office Commission, after a period of consultation and with the consent of the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, is supposed to provide guidelines on these accounts.  In many European jurisdictions, such annual accounts provide information, on the scale, rather than the sources, of party finance.  Two really obvious ways of avoiding political donation laws are pseudo-commercial payments and pseudo-loans. In Australia, all payments to political parties over a threshold have to be disclosed, whether they are donations or not.  Even though the parties somewhat implausibly classify a small minority of payments as donations, citizens can make up their own minds by inspecting the register of payments.  In the UK, all loans and their interest rates must now be disclosed.  Previously, British parties got away with pretending big donations were loans and therefore not subject to specific disclosure.  If the guidelines require details of individual payments and loans, not just aggregates, it will go some way towards reducing the likelihood of political finance scandals in the future.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Business Money and Political Corruption in Ireland

  1. Those politicians who claim, when caught, that they didn’t do anything for the money/favours/donations are right. Wealthy bastards give them money or other ‘treats’ in order to be able to continue to operate as usual. Who facilitated the looting of this country by bankers and their pals? You’re right. The politicians who were voted in by YOU.

  2. Thanks for sharing. In 2012 Ireland ranked 25th out of 176 in Transparency International’s annual Corruption Perceptions Index, worse than the average for Western Europe, ranking joint 11th with Austria of the E.U member states. This position is the country’s worst since 2003. During the years before the Celtic Tiger (1995–2007), political corruption was at its worst with many politicians suspected of corruption, while financial corruption was at its peak during the Celtic Tiger years. In 2003 Ireland signed the United Nations Convention against Corruption treaty and ratified it on 11 November 2011.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s